Measuring surface energy for successful bonding

      Why measure the surface tension before bonding ?

Surface energy, also called surface tension, is a good indicator to characterize the suitability of your materials to be bonded with an industrial tape or adhesive.

This concept highlights the way in which the molecules of a fluid or a material are attracted to each other and to the molecules of another environment.

Low surface energy materials, such as Teflon, PTFE or polyethylene, are difficult to bond and require the use of appropriate adhesive tapes or glues and/or specific treatment to increase their surface energy.

This is why surface tension is a fundamental concept in the field of technical tapes and adhesives. It is sometimes necessary to measure it in order to achieve a difficult bond, especially for a permanent assembly.

 

Little experiment to understand surface tension

To illustrate the surface energy of a material, we observe the behaviour of a water drop on this substrate. The larger the contact area between the drop and the material, the higher the surface energy. The ability of a liquid to spread on the surface of a solid is called "wetting".

High surface energy materials are easier to wet than low surface energy materials.

In the photo above, the left side of the stainless steel substrate has a low surface energy due to the addition of a non-stick treatment. The right hand side, untreated, has a high surface energy and the water drop spreads. This part is therefore more likely to be effectively bonded or glued.

The ease with which an adhesive wets the surface of a material therefore depends on the surface energy of the material. This is expressed in units of energy per surface. Its unit of measurement is usually expressed in "dyne" (1 dyne/cm = 1 mJ/m) or in mN/m.

We will come back to the notion of wetting/wettability in detail later.

      The 3 categories of surface energy of materials

LOW SURFACE ENERGIES (< 36 dynes/cm)*	MEDIUM SURFACE ENERGIES (36 to 300 dynes/cm)*	HIGH SURFACE ENERGIES (> 300 dynes/cm)*
Molecules on the surface of low surface energy materials are very little attracted to other molecules, especially adhesive molecules. Low surface energy materials are therefore very difficult to bond.	Medium surface energy is quite relative and lies between the spreading wetting film and the spherical drop.	The molecules on the surface are very strongly attracted to the molecules around it. Materials with high surface energy, most metals, are easy to wet and therefore easy to bond.
LSE (Low Surface Energy) plastics : Plastics with the lowest surface energy, such as polypropylene, polyethylene, polystyrene and many thermolacquered paints. These plastics have a real resistance to wetting and require very specific adhesive solutions to remedy this.   Engeneering plastics : They include polycarbonate, acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS) polyurethane foams, many composites and paints. They are stiffer, stronger and more temperature resistant than BES plastics. They are slightly less difficult to bond but require extensive processing.   Be aware that "non-stick" release agents such as polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) can be problematic for bonding.	Traditional materials : glass, ceramics, concrete, wood, fabric, leather, cement, stone...   They are fairly easy to bond/glue, but there are specific factors to consider for each one, including surface preparation and cleanliness.   Engeneering plastics : Most engineering plastics can also be considered medium surface energy materials (see left column). These plastics straddle both categories.	Metals : lead, tin, zinc, aluminum, steel, stainless steel, copper... They are easy to bond/glue with a proper surface preparation.   Adhesives and tapes are particularly suitable solutions for this type of material. They can even provide additional qualities to a bonding/assembly, such as thermal insulation, electrical insulation, filling (jointing, sealing).

* generally accepted theoretical reference values

      Classification of materials by surface energy

Table updated regularly from our laboratory tests.

TYPE OF SURFACE ENERGY	NATURE	ABREVIATION OR SYMBOL	MATERIAL	TRADE NAMES	VALUE (DYNE/CM)
High surface energy	Metals	Cu	Copper		1103
		Al	Aluminium		840
		Zn	Zinc		753
		Inox	Stainless steel		700 - 1100
		Sn	Tin		526
		Pb	Lead		458
Medium surface energy   Examples of suitable adhesive tapes: ADEZIF MV282 ADEZIF MV823 ADEZIF MV843 ADEZIF MV812 ADEZIF MV550 ...	Traditional materials	-	Enameled or glazed ceramics		250 - 500
		-	Unglazed ceramics		200 - 400
		-	Glass		200 - 300
		-	Cement		70
		-	Wood		40 - 50
		-	Synthetic/polyester fabric		45
	Engeneering plastics	PI	Polyimide	Kapton	50
		PF	Phenoplast/Phenol-formaldehyde resins		47
		PA	Polyamide	Nylon, Rilsan	46
		-	Alkyd enamel		45
		PET	PolyEthylene Terephtalate	Alkyd	43
		EP	Epoxy paint		43
		PUR	Polyurethane		43
		ABS	Acrylonitrile butadiene styrene	Cycolac, Abson	42
		PC	Polycarbonate	Lexan, Makrolon, Arla	42
		PVCr	Rigid PolyVinyl Chloride	Forex, Komacel	39
		PPE	PolyPhenyl Ether		38
		PPO	Polyphenylene oxide	Noryl	38
		PMMA	Poly(Methyl MethAcrylate)	Plexiglass, Acrylex, Polivar	38
Low surface energy   Examples of suitable ahdesive tapes: ADEZIF MV708 ADEZIF TF085 ADEZIF 4425 ADEZIF NT239 ADEZIF PS850 ...   Examples of suitable glues : ADEZIF HM204 ADEZIF HM404 ADEZIF HM408 ADEZIF HM484 ADEZIF HM960 ...	LSE plastics	PS	Polystyrene		36
		POM	Polyacetal/Polyoxymethylene Acetal	Derlin	36
		EVA	Ethylene-Vinyl Acetate		33
		PE	Polyethylene		31
		PP	Polypropylene	Akylux, Ethylux	29
		PVF	PolyVinyl Fluoride	Tedlar	28
		PTFE	Polytetrafluoroethylene	Teflon, Dyneon	18

Be careful with some substrates :

• Soft PVC: migration of plasticizers
• Metals and alloys: possible presence of an oxide layer
• Epoxy powder paints: surface tension agents and other additives modifying the characteristics of the paint to optimize its resistance to environmental constraints (gloss, scratch resistance, temperature...)
• ...

Always check if your surface to be bonded has been covered with a special coating (paint, epoxy paint, varnish, non-stick release agents...). On these surfaces, the material to be bonded is the coating, not the material underneath !

For each application, ask for technical expertise to find the right single-sided, double-sided tape or adhesive.

      Define surface energy: Fundamentals

By measuring the surface tension of a solid material and the surface tension of an adhesive mass, it will be possible to choose the appropriate adhesive tape or glue and/or treat the surface to be bonded in order to obtain the desired wettability and optimize your bonding.

Surface energy of solids: the wetting

As seen previously, when a drop of fluid is deposited on a solid, it will spread more or less well on its surface by forming an angle called "contact angle" between the fluid/air interface and the solid surface. This phenomenon is called "wetting".

• Low surface tension of the liquid = Wetting liquid
• High surface energy of the substrate = Easy to wet substrate

 

 

Surface tension of liquids

Have you ever observed some of these phenomena in your daily life? Insects walking on water, dew beading on the petals of a flower, sugar soaking up coffee, or a water drop hanging without falling? These fun facts are all the effect of the surface tension of liquids.

It is a physico-chemical phenomenon linked to the molecular interactions of a fluid: that is to say the way in which its molecules are attracted to each other on the one hand, and to the molecules of another material on the other.

 

Molecules within a fluid exert forces of attraction or repulsion between them:

• Van der Waals force (attraction)
• Electrostatic force (attraction or repulsion, hydrogen bond)

These molecules are always positionned in the lowest energy configuration within the same fluid in order to reach an energy balance.

 

 

In a system involving several environments, the molecular interactions are unbalanced: the molecules located at the interface interact with those of the other environment, but those located within the matter interact only with their fellow molecules.

The system naturally tends towards and equilibrium corresponding to the configuration of the lowest energy. It then modifies its geometry to decrease the area of the interface with the other environment. The force that maintains the system in this configuration is the surface tension.

 

Surface tension is a good indicator of the ability of a fluid to wet and therefore of the ability of an adhesive mass to adhere to a given surface.

      Methods to measure surface tension

Here are two examples of methods frequently used to measure surface energy. Our application engineer can guide you in your measurements, but also carry out certain tests in our internal laboratory, in order to guide you in the choice of your products and the preparation of your surfaces to be bonded.

Sessile drop method

Using a goniometer, composed of a motorized syringe connected to a data processing software, we are able to deposite a drop of liquid on a solid substrate under study. A camera collects and records the images of the experiment. We observe the shape of the drop, the contact angle, and by cross-referencing these data with the determined surface tension of the fluid, we are able to calculate the surface energy of the substrate.

 

 

Note: Water is generally used for the basic surface energy measurement. It is easy to purify and has a low viscosity, so surface equilibrium can be reached in less than a minute. Other fluids, such as certain solvents or oils, can be used to refine the measurements later.

Test inks method

The test ink method of measuring surface energy is a simple and fast process, requiring less equi^ment than other methods. It is particularly used to measure the surface energy of common materials, such as plastic, glass, recycled or composite materials. The tester has several bottles of ink, corresponding to different ranges of surface energy values.

• After cleaning and possibly pre-treating the surface to be tested, the ink corresponding to the highest surface energy is applied with a brush integrated in the bottle.
• If the applied ink is stable for 2 seconds, the surface is easily wettable and thus adherable.
• If the ink beads on the substrate, the test is continued with the next lower value and so on, until the applied ink is stable.

The surface tension of the material is equal to the value of the last ink tested that showed a bad wetting for at least 2 seconds.

Note: The test ink method requires a critical approach to the measurement results. The values obtained are within a relative range of results. In all cases, the inks used must comply with DIN 53364 or ISO 8296.

      Obstacles, contaminations and treatments

Contamination of the surface to be bonded can cause:

• A loss of tack (instant adhesion)
• A decrease in wetting
• Reduced adhesive/substrat contact
• Reduced adhesive strength

 

These obstacles reduce the adhesion surface, weaken the bonding and increase the chances of the tape tearing. In order to prevent this kind of inconvenience, we remind you that a degreasing according to precise methods is essential before any gluing/assembly.

The application of a bonding primer can also be used to increase the surface energy of a substrate, especially for your difficult bonding (low surface energy materials).

See our page on surface preparation before applying an adhesive solution for more details and technical tips.